More Reviews

Reviews for 2023

May 2023 - New York Wine Classic

May 2023 - New York Wine Classic
This month's Wine feature is New York Wine Classic Wines

New York Wine Classic Reviews

Weis Vineyards NV One Eighty Three Dessert Wine Finger Lakes
97 points
$39
A remarkably rich, delicious, and warming American fortified wine with Old World nuances that add complexity and delight; definitely a benchmark for domestic port style wine that tastes like a true vintage port.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Fortified (Port-Like)
Weis Vineyards 2020 Noble Select Riesling
95 points
$109
A delicious, round and welcoming sweet wine that will be fantastic with cheeses and desserts.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2021  Lemberger
94 points
$25
A super earthy and savory red that will be superb with rich fare, especially game.
Bright Leaf Vineyard 2019 Estate Cabernet Franc
94 points
$25
Fruity and savory with excellent structure, this wine would make an excellent picnic companion with a rare roast beef sandwich.
Weis Vineyards 2021 Winzer Select A Riesling
94 points
$26
A rich, honeyed, unctuous Riesling with toothsome late harvest fruit flavors and bright acidity; this will be great with everything from cocktail hour to appetizers to desserts.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Riesling (Sweet)
City Winery 2020 Vin De Glaciere Uva Blanca Vineyard Riesling
94 points
$28
An unctuous, balanced, and delicious sweet wine that will be great with desserts and cheeses.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2020 Estate Cabernet Franc
94 points
$57
A rich, polished Cabernet Franc with savory, dark fruit flavors and fine old world balance.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2020 Reserve Cabernet Franc
94 points
$59
A bright, flavorful Cabernet Franc with delicious, layered flavors and an exquisitely supple texture.
Winery Of Ellicottville 2022 West Wind Vineyard Semi-Sweet Riesling
93 points
$19
Best Buy
A graceful, delightfully fruity and balanced Riesling with great typicity and sense of place.
93 points $19 Best Buy
Bright Leaf Vineyard 2019 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon
93 points
$23
Well balanced fruit and acid with moderate alcohol and grippy tannins that will soften with time and pair well with a roast.
One Woman 2019  Sauvignon Blanc
93 points
$25
A concentrated citrus driven Sauvignon Blanc that refreshes palate.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Sauvignon Blanc
Weis Vineyards 2020  Blaufrankisch
93 points
$25
A beautifully balanced and nuanced Blaufrankisch that will be very versatile and cellar worthy.
City Winery 2020 Au Naturel Uva Blanca Vineyard Syrah
93 points
$32
A rich and chewy Syrah with great flavor, varietal character, and long lived structure.
Ravines 2020 Le Petit Caporal Red Blend Finger Lakes
93 points
$34
A rich and supple Cabernet Franc with great flavor and structure for now or later.
One Woman 2017  Cabernet Franc
93 points
$35
A graceful, herbal Cabernet Franc with spot on New York terroir and table appeal.
One Woman 2016 Estate Reserve Chardonnay
93 points
$42
A plush, oak-driven Chardonnay with tropical fruit in fine support of the fancy oak.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2020 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon
93 points
$59
Cooler climate Cabernet with enough power and finesse to compete with quality Cabernet from around the country.
Clovis Point 2019  Petit Verdot
93 points
$75
A wonderful and rich table wine to impress your dinner guests.
Deer Run Winery NV Conesus White Blend Finger Lakes
92 points
$12
Best Buy
A delicious off-dry blend of white hybrid grapes that balance each other beautifully.
92 points $12 Best Buy
Fulkerson NV Sparklin Diamond
92 points
$16
Best Buy
A delicious off-dry sparkler with rich ripe fruit for days.
92 points $16 Best Buy
Johnson Estate NV Old Oak Ruby Estate Grown Bourbon Barrel Aged Dessert Wine Lake Erie
92 points
$18
Best Buy
A spicy and distinctive domestic port with lovely layers of bourbon barrel notes.
92 points $18 Best Buy
Fulkerson 2022 Bunch Select Reserve Riesling
92 points
$21
A serious, and seriously dry, Riesling with a classic cut and loads of minerality; a superb choice for oysters.
Billsboro 2021 Sawmill Creek Vineyards Riesling
92 points
$22
A rich and layered Riesling with nice touches of late harvest and varietal character.
Lucas Vineyards 2020 Reserve Estate Collection Cabernet Sauvignon
92 points
$25
Savory and true cooler Cabernet Sauvignon; pair with a steak and chimichurri sauce.
One Woman 2019  Gewurztraminer
92 points
$28
A lively, lightly floral Gewurztraminer with great flavor and poise.
Clovis Point 2022  Sauvignon Blanc
92 points
$29
A delicious tropical Sauvignon Blanc with a nice core of minerality; this will be very versatile.
Wagner Vineyards 2021 Ice Riesling
92 points
$29
A juicy and satisfying dessert wine with great flavor and balance.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Iced Wine Frozen After Harvest
Wagner Vineyards 2022 Ice Vidal
92 points
$29
A juicy and toothsome sweet wine with fine balance and style.
City Winery 2020 Uva Blanca Vineyard Reserve Merlot
92 points
$36
A polished, Old World styled Merlot with ripe, savory flavors and table friendly acidity.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2020 Meritage Red Blend Finger Lakes
92 points
$44
A juicy, spicy, inviting red blend that will provide plenty of pleasure now or later.
Clovis Point 2019 Vintners Select North Fork Of Long Island
92 points
$49
A Left Bank styled red blend that should do very well on a local farm to table menu in NYC.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV Schooner White Blend Finger Lakes
91 points
$14
Best Buy
A toothsome and supple white blend sipper that is sure to please.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best White Blend (Vinifera)
91 points $14 Best Buy
Ryan William Vineyard 2020 Estate Dry Riesling
91 points
$18
Best Buy
A lively, mouthwatering Riesling that will cover a lot of bases.
91 points $18 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2021 Dry Riesling
91 points
$18
Best Buy
A fruit-forward and satisfying Riesling with a nice backbone of minerality and acidity.
91 points $18 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2021 Unoaked Chardonnay
91 points
$18
Best Buy
A clean, precise, and balanced unoaked Chardonnay with excellent flavor, structure, and restraint.
91 points $18 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2021 Perle Rosé Finger Lakes
91 points
$19
An elegant and balanced Rosé sparkler that will be very versatile.
Weis Vineyards 2021 Heart Of The Lake NY81.0315.17 Aravelle
91 points
$19
Bright fruit and vibrant acidity combined with a touch of sweetness make this a great choice for spicy fish and poultry dishes.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Other Hybrid White Varietal
Lucas Vineyards 2020 Reserve Estate Collection Cabernet Franc
91 points
$22
A chewy, multilayered Cabernet Franc that will be very versatile.
Deer Run Winery 2021  Cabernet Franc
91 points
$26
A stimulating Cabernet Franc that will be great with a meaty meal.
Fulkerson 2019 Reserve Syrah
91 points
$27
A bright, piquant, savory Syrah with nice oak, varietal character, and table appeal.
Weis Vineyards 2020  Cabernet Franc
91 points
$29
A bright and buoyant Cabernet Franc for all occasions.
Lucas Vineyards 2020 Reserve Estate Collection Red Blend Finger Lakes
91 points
$30
A round and seamless Cabernet Franc with savory fruit, nice oak, and chewy tannins.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2016 Brut Method Champenoise Finger Lakes
91 points
$44.99
A well poised Champagne-like bubbly that will be sensational at the table.
91 points $44.99
Clovis Point 2020  Malbec
91 points
$45
A savory and evenly balanced Malbec that will be versatile.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV White Stag Blend Finger Lakes
90 points
$9
Best Buy
A bright and bouncy off-dry white blend that will make a perfect patio wine.
90 points $9 Best Buy
Evl White NV EVL White Diamond-Riesling Blend Diamond
90 points
$16
Best Buy
A well poised white hybrid with juicy fruit flavors and crunchy balancing fruit tannins.
90 points $16 Best Buy
Fulkerson 2022 Sweet Riesling
90 points
$17
Best Buy
A pure, not too sweet Riesling with nice layers of flavor and earthy tones; will be great with spicy Asian fare.
90 points $17 Best Buy
Château LaFayette Reneau 2022 Estate Rosé Cabernet Franc
90 points
$18
Best Buy
A round and welcoming Rosé with pinpoint balance and toothsome fruit flavors.
90 points $18 Best Buy
Damiani Wine Cellars NV Bollicinie Finger Lakes
90 points
$18
Best Buy
A supple and savory sparkler that will be great with fish and seafood dishes.
90 points $18 Best Buy
Fulkerson 2020  Cabernet Franc
90 points
$18
Best Buy
A nicely layered Cabernet Franc that has a nice combination of sweet and savory flavors with a floral high note.
90 points $18 Best Buy
Point Of The Bluff Vineyards 2019 Dry Riesling
90 points
$18
Best Buy
A lovely, savory Riesling with restraint and nice varietal character.
90 points $18 Best Buy
Middleburgh Winery 2022 Blackberry Wine New York State
90 points
$20
A pure, dry berry wine with great versatility.
Awards: 2023 New York Wine Classic - Best Fruit Wine
Rooftop Reds 2021 Barrel Fermented Chardonnay
90 points
$22
A round and creamy Chardonnay with juicy, palate-refreshing flavors.
Weis Vineyards 2021 Winzer Select K Riesling
90 points
$24
A rock solid dry Riesling with mouthwatering flavors and acidity.
Fulkerson 2020  Pinot Noir
90 points
$25
A nice layered and nuanced Pinot Noir; give this one some time to open up.
One Woman 2018  Chardonnay
90 points
$25
A rich, tropical and savory, oak-forward Chardonnay sipper.
South Salem Winery 2018 Reserve Malbec
90 points
$27
A rich, ripe, Old World styled Malbec that will be great at the table.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2020  Merlot
90 points
$31
A tangy, appetizing, oak-accented Merlot with nice fruit, depth and balance.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2021 Estate Unoaked Noiret
90 points
$31
A very savory, distinctive, and dry red wine that will excel at the hunter's table.
Clovis Point 2019  Cabernet Franc
90 points
$45
A toasty, oaky Cabernet Franc with attractive dark berry fruit and mocha notes.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV Pink Cat Blush Catawba
89 points
$8
Best Buy
A vibrant and flavorful off-dry Rosé with nice balance.
89 points $8 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2021 Estate Grown Semi Dry Riesling
89 points
$15
Best Buy
A clean, tasty, fruit-forward Riesling for all occasions.
89 points $15 Best Buy
Ryan William Vineyard 2020 Estate Riesling
89 points
$17
A tasty, well-balanced Riesling that livens the palate.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2021  Gewurztraminer
89 points
$18
A supple and earthy Gewurztraminer for sipping.
Ravines 2022 Estate Grown Sauvignon Blanc
89 points
$18
A very nice combination of juicy tropical fruit and earth that will work well at the table.
Point Of The Bluff Vineyards 2019 Reserve Riesling
89 points
$21
A dry, savory and refreshing Riesling that will shine at the table.
Billsboro 2022 Sawmill Creek Vineyards Rosé of Pinot Noir-Syrah Finger Lakes
89 points
$22
A nicely articulated and zippy adult Rosé with ripe fruit and appetizing structure.
Wagner Vineyards 2021 Caywood East Vineyard Riesling
89 points
$24
An interesting, mineral driven Riesling for whetting the appetite or with light appetizers.
Weis Vineyards 2021  Pinot Blanc
89 points
$24
Pleasant and uncomplicated, a good everyday wine for around the house.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2021 Osprey Red Blend Cayuga Lake
89 points
$25
A tangy, meaty red perfected poised for pot roasts and pork loins.
Atwater 2021 East-West Vineyard Dry Riesling
89 points
$27
A pleasant Riesling with nice acidity and earthy notes.
Atwater 2021  Cabernet Franc
89 points
$28
A light and lively Cabernet Franc with tangy berry flavors.
Weis Vineyards 2020  Cabernet Sauvignon
89 points
$29
A solid and honest example of the flavors and aromas of cool climate Cabernet.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2020  Cabernet Sauvignon
89 points
$31
A hearty and robust red wine that would do well in a steak house, and please both Old and New World wine drinkers.
Clovis Point 2022 White Merlot
89 points
$32
A smooth and polished dry Rosé for weekend revelry.
Clovis Point 2022 Black Label Barrel Fermented Chardonnay
89 points
$38
A nice, dry, nutty, and elegant Chardonnay for sipping or the table.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2020 Reserve Merlot
89 points
$59
A dense, oaky Merlot with dark brooding fruit and firm woody tannins; give this some time to resolve.
Clovis Point 2019 Archeology Red Blend North Fork Of Long Island
89 points
$65
Lean green herbs with pops of red fruit; pair at a cook out with grilled sausage and a summer garden salad.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV White Cat Niagara
88 points
$8
Best Buy
A robust Niagara with ample fruit and sweetness for sweet wine fans.
88 points $8 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2021 Reserve Estate Collection Syrah
88 points
$12
Best Buy
A dry and lively Syrah that will be nice with light meat dishes.
88 points $12 Best Buy
Deer Run Winery NV Moscato White Blend Finger Lakes
88 points
$14
Best Buy
A distinctively aromatic white wine blend with deep dried tropical fruit flavors.
88 points $14 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2021  Vignoles
88 points
$14
Best Buy
Nice citrus and stone fruit flavors with an interesting white cherry finish.
88 points $14 Best Buy
Roads End Orchards NV Semi-Sweet Red Currant Wine New York State
88 points
$15
Best Buy
Nice purity and balance make this a versatile fruit wine for desserts, cheeses and cocktails.
88 points $15 Best Buy
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2021  Sauvignon Blanc
88 points
$17
A crisp, juicy Sauvignon Blanc that will brighten a summer day.
Lucas Vineyards 2021  Cabernet Franc
88 points
$17
A dry, savory, well balanced Cabernet Franc that will be great with a meaty meal.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2021 Semi-Dry Riesling
88 points
$18
An earthy, chewy, lemony Riesling for any occasion.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2021 Crosswind White Blend Cayuga Lake
88 points
$19
A crisp and quenching, lightly floral white wine that will be great with oysters.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2021  Chardonnay
88 points
$21
A well balanced and appetizing lightly oaked Chardonnay that will be versatile.
Clovis Point 2022 Rosé North Fork Of Long Island
88 points
$22
A dry, zippy, and poised adult Rosé.
One Woman 2020  Gruner Veltliner
88 points
$25
A zippy Gruner sipper for all occasions.
South Salem Winery 2018 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon
88 points
$27
A rich and oaky Cabernet with pronounced cherry notes.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2019  Cabernet Franc
88 points
$29
A dusty, chewy, oaky Cabernet France for a fatty steak now or in the cellar for later.
Damiani Wine Cellars 2021 Davis Vineyard Dry Riesling
88 points
$32
A clean, crisp, and even Riesling aperitif.
Billsboro 2021 Sawmill Creek Vineyards & Leidenfrost Pinot Noir
88 points
$34
A dry, savory Pinot Noir that will work nicely at the table, especially with salads with meat or tuna.
Winery Of Ellicottville 2021 Perfetto Vineyard Reserve Pinot Noir
88 points
$42
A well balanced, dry and savory Pinot Noir with nice chewy tannins.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV Red Cat Dark Concord
87 points
$8
Best Buy
Mix with peanut butter whiskey for killer PBJ shots.
87 points $8 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards NV Miss Behavin Finger Lakes
87 points
$12
Best Buy
Exactly the sweet and approachable adult version of grape juice that it is supposed to be.
87 points $12 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2021  Cayuga
87 points
$14
Best Buy
A solid example of cold climate white wine that is good enough to be an everyday table wine.
87 points $14 Best Buy
Middleburgh Winery 2019 Single Vineyard Estate Seyval Blanc
87 points
$14
Best Buy
A good table wine that would be right at home paired with a light lunch after hiking in the Adirondacks.
87 points $14 Best Buy
Château LaFayette Reneau 2020 Estate Riesling
87 points
$15
Best Buy
A piquant, dry-yet-fruity Riesling that whets the appetite.
87 points $15 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2020 Freelings Creek Reserve Founders Red Blend Lake Erie
87 points
$16
A respectable table wine to keep around the house to pair with a random Tuesday dinner.
Johnson Estate 2021 Freelings Creek Reserve Marechal Foch
87 points
$16
A nice chocolatey off-dry red that is not too sweet.
Point Of The Bluff Vineyards 2022  Chardonnay
87 points
$17
An earthy Chardonnay for a nice meal, particularly vegetarian.
Billsboro 2022 Sawmill Creek Vineyards Riesling
87 points
$22
A crisp and crunchy Riesling that will be great with oysters.
Billsboro 2022 Sawmill Creek Vineyards Albarino
87 points
$26
A savory, earthy white that will shine at the table.
Ravines 2020 Estate Pinot Noir
87 points
$27
A heavily oaked Pinot Noir for a meaty meal.
Rooftop Reds NV Blau Nouveau Blaufrankisch
87 points
$30
A juicy and scintillating red that will liven up a meal.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2021 Estate Iced Cabernet Franc
87 points
$83
An interesting, meaty dessert wine to try with charcuterie.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV Red Cat Red Blend Finger Lakes
86 points
$8
Best Buy
Add a splash of club soda to balance out the sweetness and for a refreshing spritzer at your next picnic.
86 points $8 Best Buy
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2022 Estate Valvin Muscat Chardonnay Blend Valvin Muscat
86 points
$25
Nice rich fruit and acid character with solid typicity of the grape; will make a good pairing with a fruit and cheese board.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2022 Estate Semi-Dry Riesling
86 points
$27
A crisp, earthy Riesling with nice structure and fruit tannins.
Rooftop Reds 2020 Reserve Cabernet Franc
86 points
$40
A very dry, oak forward Cabernet Franc for a rich meal.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2021 Dry Rosé Finger Lakes
85 points
$17
A pleasantly dry and savory Rosé for a summer day and salads.
Johnson Estate NV Old Oak Gold Estate Grown Bourbon Barrel Aged Dessert Wine Lake Erie
85 points
$18
Salted almonds on vanilla, coconut, and lemon sorbet.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards NV Solera Sherry Finger Lakes
85 points
$21
Pair with a dessert course and a full bodied cigar.
Middleburgh Winery 2021 Synergy Estate Grown Red Blend New York State
85 points
$24
A serviceable red with zippy acidity to cut through the richness of grilled meats.
South Salem Winery 2018 Reserve Cabernet Franc
85 points
$27
A earthy, rustic red for the hunter's table.
City Winery 2021 Uva Blanca Vineyard Pet-Nat Riesling
85 points
$29
A very savory and somewhat brackish pet nat with lots of table appeal with umami-forward meals.
Fulkerson 2022 Niagara Iced Wine Seneca Lake
85 points
$32
A savory and very herbal and earthy iced wine for exotic cheeses.
Lucas Vineyards NV Blues White Blend Finger Lakes
84 points
$12
A somewhat uneven white wine with a dusty nose and juicy palate.
Point Of The Bluff Vineyards 2021  Riesling
84 points
$17
An earthy, dry Riesling for the table.
Billsboro 2021 Sawmill Creek Vineyards Chardonnay
84 points
$18
A crisp, dry, linear Chardonnay for the table.
Middleburgh Winery 2021 Best Day Rosé New York State
83 points
$18
A dry, earthy Rosé for the table.
Tabora Farm & Winery 2022 Sparkel Blanc Seneca Lake
83 points
$20
An earthy bubbly that will be nice with cheeses.
Point Of The Bluff Vineyards 2020 Resereve Pinot Noir
83 points
$35
A light and savory Pinot Noir.
Lucas Vineyards 2021 Estate Collection Semi-Dry Riesling
82 points
$15
A very lemony and dusty Riesling for the table.
Colloca Estate Winery 2020 Lake Effect Vineyard Dry Riesling
82 points
$19
A mature, very umami-driven Riesling for the table.
Lucas Vineyards 2021 Estate Collection Dry Riesling
81 points
$15
A curiously lemony Riesling for the table.
Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards 2021 Unoaked Chardonnay
81 points
$16
A very dry, light, and oily Chardonnay for the table.
Fulkerson 2021  Gruner Veltliner
80 points
$15
A curiously starchy Gruner for the table.
Shortcut: https://www.tastings.com/Calendar-Wine/Review-2023-06-06-New-York-Wine-Classic.aspx