More Reviews

Reviews for 2024

May 2024 - New York Wine Classic

May 2024 - New York Wine Classic
This month's Wine feature is New York Wine Classic Wines

New York Wine Classic Reviews

Weis Vineyards 2018 Ice Wine Riesling
97 points
$89
Beautiful complexity of flavor with light florals and minerality as counterpoints to its pronounced stone fruit, orchard fruit, and tropical citrus tones; this is world class Eiswein.
Awards: '2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Dessert Wine' 2024 New York Wine Classic - Governor's Cup Winner - Best Wine
Fulkerson 2023 Estate Rosé Syrah
94 points
$16
Best Buy
A superb bright and refreshing Rosé with oodles of summer fruits, berries, and pinpoint acidity.
Awards: '2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Pink Wine' 2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Rosé (0 to 2% RS)
94 points $16 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2022  Gruner Veltliner
94 points
$21
Tasty, super clean and well executed; one of the finest examples to be made in the US.
Awards: 2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Gruner Veltliner
Weis Vineyards 2022 Heart Of The Lake White Aravelle NY.81
94 points
$21
Delicate floral aromas are the star of this white wine with hints of stone fruit in the back ground; an easy drinker that transports you to a warm Spring day.
Awards: 2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Hybrid White Wine
Atwater 2022  Cabernet Franc
94 points
$32
Top of the list for FLX red wines; depth of dark red and black fruits with a semi-carbonic candied lift, savory herbs and light barrel spice, all integrated and in balance.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2022 Antonov Sauvignon Blanc
94 points
$32
Orchard fruits, melon, and a bit of tropical fruit balanced with a hit of the classic green herbs note, this is exactly what you want from cooler climate Sauvignon Blanc.
Awards: 2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Sauvignon Blanc
Bedell Cellars 2022  Cabernet Franc
94 points
$38
A delightful Cabernet Franc that has a mix of red and black fruit with a lingering finish.
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Marechal Foch
93 points
$16
Best Buy
A delicious, rather Zinfandel-like Marechal Foch that deserves a seat at the dinner table.
93 points $16 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2023 Dry Rosé Of Cabernet Franc
93 points
$18
Best Buy
Charming and crushable, loaded with red berries and a pleasant, light herbal character as a counter balance.
93 points $18 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2022 Dry Riesling
93 points
$20
Best Buy
Very linear and focused with good mineral backbone and tart fruit with a touch of honeysuckle roundness; drinks very Austrian in style.
93 points $20 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2022 Winzer Select A Riesling
93 points
$28
A delicious mouthwatering 'sweet' Riesling that due to its complexity, and a touch of botrytis, is not too sweet and will be very versatile with desserts, cheeses, and spicy cuisine.
Weis Vineyards 2022 Terroir Limestone Riesling
93 points
$34
Drinks like a citrus-focused and mineral-driven Mosel Trocken Feinherb Kabinett; kudos.
Bright Leaf Vineyard 2018 Eclair Cuvée Brut Finger Lakes
93 points
$36
Well-balanced structure with direct flavors of orchard fruit, citrus, and mild lees aging; a crowd pleaser for any lovers of traditional sparkling wines.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2020 Caya Cabernet Franc
93 points
$37
A rich Cabernet Franc that possesses both complexity and intensity of fruit with well-balanced structure; pair this with a hearty meal.
Weis Vineyards 2021 Winzer Select Edel Süss Finger Lakes
93 points
$59.99
A top notch dessert Riesling with precise fruit flavors, balanced acidity, and a proper delicate balance of botrytis.
93 points $59.99
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2023 Estate Rosé Long Island
92 points
$19
Best Buy
A crowd pleasing Rosé with enough acid and herbaceous character balancing the red berry fruits to make this suitable for light dinner pairings.
92 points $19 Best Buy
Weis Vineyards 2022 Semi Dry Riesling
92 points
$20
Best Buy
Reminiscent of proper Mosel Kabinett style Riesling; delicious and exactly what you want from FLX, to drink by itself or pair with pork, light spring greens, or spicy foods.
92 points $20 Best Buy
Atwater 2023 Dry Rosé Seneca Lake
92 points
$27
Refreshing but still has some stuffing and pop to the fruit and green herbaciousness that will have this pairing well at barbecues and boat parties.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2023 Diosa Late Harvest White Wine Long Island
92 points
$37
Exactly what is wanted and expected from a top quality dessert wine from the region; pair with candied fruit and nuts as well as blue cheese to end a meal at your favorite NYC French bistro.
Fulkerson NV Estate Semi-Dry Riesling
91 points
$17
Best Buy
Nice minerality with acid and sweetness in balance exhibiting good range of fruit and floral notes; a lovely option for a cheese board on your boat.
91 points $17 Best Buy
Johnson Estate NV Estate Grown Lake Effect White Blend Lake Erie
91 points
$19
A lovely, soft Summer sipper with enticing floral notes and crisp fruity flavors.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2020 Christians Cuvee Pinot Noir
91 points
$125
Light kola nut with chocolate and ripe cherry; very tasty.
Awards: 2024 New York Wine Classic - Best Pinot Noir
Fulkerson 2023 Estate Dornfelder
90 points
$17
Best Buy
A zesty, jammy, almost off-dry red that will be superb with BBQ; serve with a light chill.
90 points $17 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Pinot Noir
90 points
$19
Clean, dialed in wine making with waves of crunchy red fruit and ample oak for those that like the French oak baking spice influence.
Johnson Estate NV Estate Grown Brut Rosé Pinot Noir
90 points
$29
A creamy, round, and welcoming Rosé bubbly with expressive, ripe Pinot Noir fruit.
Bedell Cellars 2022 Taste Red Blend North Fork of Long Island
90 points
$45
A surprisingly rich red blend from the region and an easy go-to selection for summer grilling season.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2020 Grapes Of Roth Merlot
90 points
$50
Velvety smooth with an underlying savory foundation tailor-made for the table.
Clovis Point 2020 Archeology Red Blend North Fork of Long Island
90 points
$65
A complex and well balanced blend to suit a wide array of tastes and pairings.
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Toasted Oak Chardonnay
89 points
$16
Best Buy
A white wine filled with the flavors of oak, lemon, and vanilla and just enough acid to give a fresh finish.
89 points $16 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2022 Estate Collection Semi Dry Riesling
89 points
$16
Best Buy
Acid and sugar are in balance and a great linear minerality is present from nose to finish.
89 points $16 Best Buy
Airy Acres Vineyard 2022 Semi-Dry Riesling
89 points
$18
A very food friendly dry Riesling; intense, zesty and balanced with lip smacking tart fruits and a clean finish.
Johnson Estate NV Estate Grown Lake Effect Red Blend Lake Erie
89 points
$19
A fruity, round, and juicy crowd-pleasing red blend that will make a great summer sipper; serve with a slight chill.
Winery of Ellicottville NV Reserve Collection Dry Rosé New York State
89 points
$21
Tart strawberries underpin a tangy, zesty Rosé that prickles the tastebuds.
Weis Vineyards 2022  Chardonnay
89 points
$24
Those that enjoy buttery aromas and flavors will flock towards this Chardonnay.
Lucas Vineyards 2022 Reserve Estate Collection Cabernet Franc
89 points
$25
Dense red fruit blends seamlessly with earth, leather, and spice to create a tasty red wine that will pair nicely with a fatty piece of meat.
Atwater 2023 Petillant Naturel Finger Lakes
89 points
$26
A tangy, mouthwatering Pet-Nat that will whet the appetite for an exotic meal.
Atwater 2022 Dry Riesling
89 points
$27
Nice crisp acidity with vibrant minerality on the palate and pronounced floral character on both the nose and finish.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2021 Black Currant Wine With Grape Brandy Hudson River Region
89 points
$34
With dark and concentrated fruit, it's very reminiscent of examples of cassis liqueurs from France; like a warm hug on the palate.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2022 Estate Cabernet Franc
89 points
$43
Lots of Cabernet Franc varietal character in an earthy, savory frame with a splash of vanilla-kissed oak on the lingering finish.
Deer Run Winery NV Pebble Beach Blush Finger Lakes
88 points
$12
Best Buy
A light and easy drinking patio pounder of a Rosé.
88 points $12 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Vidal Blanc
88 points
$14
Best Buy
A deceptively simple and sweet Vidal Blanc that still gives layers of flavors; pair with spicy food.
88 points $14 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2022  Vignoles
88 points
$14
Best Buy
Aromatic and refreshing, this would be a great pairing with sushi.
88 points $14 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards NV Miss Chevious Finger Lakes
88 points
$14
Best Buy
A clean, fresh, un-oaked example of Chardonnay with delicate notes of lemon and flowers.
88 points $14 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Semi-Dry Riesling
88 points
$16
A nice balance of floral and tropical with a light sweetness to balance with the notes of candied green herbs.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2020 Heavens Ice Cider Hudson River Region
88 points
$23
A rich apple Cider with very pleasant and concentrated apple flavor and a nice lift of traditional baking spices.
Fulkerson 2021 Bourbon Barrel-Aged Syrah
88 points
$25
A good wine to pair with grilled or roasted lamb; a natural pairing with BBQ.
Weis Vineyards 2021  Blaufrankisch
88 points
$25
A slightly lighter take on Blaufrankish with vibrant acidity and a good balance of red fruits and subtle earthy flavors; a great wine for food pairing.
Clovis Point 2023 Black Label Chardonnay
88 points
$29
A range of light and crisp fruit that holds the oak well alongside a touch of butteriness all contribute to the unique complexity of this Chardonnay.
North Cliff Vineyards NV Bourbon Barrel-Aged Merlot
88 points
$35
An adroitly balanced Bourbon barrel-aged Merlot that delivers juicy berry pie fruit, creamy vanilla, and spice herbal nuances.
Quartz Rock Vineyard 2021 Estate Noiret
88 points
$37
A supple and Pinot Noir-like red for a savory, gamey meal; serve with slight chill.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2020 Fatalis Fatum Red Blend Long Island
88 points
$40
A nice Bordeaux blend with vibrant red fruit and a nice acidic balance with green herbs that will make it very food friendly in pairing with roasts.
Clovis Point 2021  Malbec
88 points
$45
A bit of a cooler and leaner expression of Malbec that's balanced and well-executed.
Bedell Cellars 2019 Musée Red Blend North Fork of Long Island
88 points
$75
Floral and perfumed aromas studded with black fruit and woodsy spices; quite rich and complex.
North Cliff Vineyards 2019  Cabernet Franc
88 points
$85
A plush and plentiful Cabernet Franc to wrap up a long day.
Fulkerson NV  Diamond
87 points
$15
Best Buy
A crisp and floral light white wine that will work well with summer salads.
87 points $15 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2023 Hand Picked Seyval Blanc
87 points
$15
Best Buy
A nice savory and dry white wine that will pair well with appetizers of all sorts, especially mezze and charcuterie.
87 points $15 Best Buy
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Bright Steel Chardonnay
87 points
$16
A solid Chardonnay for everyday enjoyment and carefree sipping.
Lucas Vineyards 2022 Estate Collection Dry Riesling
87 points
$16
A pleasant sweet, salted lime nose and palate character with a touch of green herb and a whisper of fruit sweetness for balance; versatile and food friendly.
Wienry of Ellicottville NV EVL Red New York State
87 points
$16
Candied red fruit drive the profile of this off-dry wine.
Fulkerson 2023 Estate Sweet Riesling
87 points
$17
A nice and varietally correct Riesling that does everything right but keeps things simple.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2022 Dry Riesling
87 points
$18
A light and refreshing sipper with aromas of white flowers and spring greens with green apple and citrus dancing on the palate.
Comerford’s Irish Boxer Winery 2023 Bubbly New York State
87 points
$21
A sparkling white wine that is fresh and fruity with a touch of sweetness; enjoy with cakes or spicy Asian fare outside during Spring.
Lucas Vineyards 2021 Reserve Estate Collection Cabernet Sauvignon
87 points
$25
A judicious use of oak pulls together tart fruit and subtle earthiness to create a lighter yet still juicy and savory style of Cabernet Sauvignon.
Clovis Point 2023  Sauvignon Blanc
87 points
$29
A lovely food wine and a nice representation of Sauvignon Blanc from the region; definitely a crowd pleaser.
Airy Acres Vineyard 2022  Cabernet Sauvignon
87 points
$32
A bright and crisp, yet savory, Cabernet Sauvignon with a boost of depth from a framework of oak.
Clovis Point 2023 White Merlot
87 points
$32
A nice savory Rosé for grilled food and salad aperitif pairings.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2021 Perle Chardonnay
87 points
$32
Walks the line between a warm climate and cool climate style Chardonnay quite well.
Hector Wine Company 2020 Sawmill Creek Estate Red Blend Finger Lakes
87 points
$46
A really good red blend for BBQs; the red and black fruit pops nicely with a bit of leather and black pepper.
Clovis Point 2019 Vintners Select Merlot
87 points
$49
A nice rich and earthy red table wine for pairing with winter roasts.
Lucas Vineyards NV Butterfly Cayuga White
86 points
$13
Best Buy
A nice off dry white wine with good acid to balance the fruit and florals.
86 points $13 Best Buy
Lucas Vineyards 2022  Seyval Blanc
86 points
$14
Best Buy
A good table wine or house wine for most occasions.
86 points $14 Best Buy
Deer Run Winery 2021  Riesling
86 points
$16
A nice and traditional FLX style of Riesling with good fruit, acid, and terroir.
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Sweet Riesling
86 points
$16
A solid 'not-too-sweet' sweet Riesling with bright honeyed fruit, zippy acidity, and crunchy fruit tannins to hold it all together.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2021 Grapes Of Roth Dry Riesling
86 points
$26
A Riesling for a Chardonnay drinker, ripe fruit flavors that would pair well with salmon and pork dishes.
North Cliff Vineyards 2021 North Cliff Vineyards Merlot
86 points
$35
Spiced red and black fruits with a nice depth of flavor.
Bedell Cellars 2020 Gallery White Blend North Fork of Long Island
86 points
$38
A nice, oaky white wine for sipping alone or enjoy with fried chicken.
Clovis Point 2020  Cabernet Franc
86 points
$45
A solid example of Cabernet Franc for pairing with roasts or grilled meats.
Atwater 2020 Skin Fermented Pinot Gris
86 points
$50
Explore this skin contact Pinot Gris with your favorite salty snack.
North Cliff Vineyards 2019  Petit Verdot
86 points
$50
A red wine that will appeal to drinkers of Bourbon barrel cherry-infused Stouts; think rich chocolate tones and some malty sweetness with light floral and cherry essence.
Clovis Point 2020  Petit Verdot
86 points
$75
Elevated tannic structure and black fruit make this a red wine that would appreciate food.
Fulkerson NV Sparklin Diamond
85 points
$15
Bursting with fruit aromatics and flowers on the palate, this is a good wine to break out for brunch or dessert.
Johnson Estate 2022 Freelings Creek Reserve Dry Riesling
85 points
$16
A great wine to bring to a potluck.
Atwater 2022  Pinot Noir
85 points
$42
Decant this red for a few hours and have it as your second bottle of the night.
Atwater 2022  Syrah
85 points
$42
Wildly perfumed blended with stemmy incense but in a pleasing way; like drinking cherry juice while surrounded by roses at a Roman Catholic mass.
Fulkerson 2022 Estate Dry Riesling
84 points
$17
Lean, dry, and crisp with tart tropical citrus and bold vegetable flavors; try this with an arugala and clementine salad or with some artichoke hearts.
Atwater 2023 Pétillant Naturel Aromella
84 points
$26
An interesting Pet-Nat with flavors that would appeal to those that like Basque cider or Lambic-style beer.
North Cliff Vineyards NV La Crush Merlot
84 points
$30
A fun food wine for those that like cooler climate and rustic expressions of Merlot.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard 2021 Grapes Of Roth Virgin Berry Dry Riesling
84 points
$32
A fresh fruity white wine that would be great for a backyard party or movie in the park.
Deer Run Winery NV Dockside Dessert Wine Finger Lakes
82 points
$19
Pair with a flourless chocolate cake topped with a balsamic reduction.
Seiche NV Grapeau Dessert Wine Lake Erie
81 points
$30
Like drinking grape jelly on toasted white bread; a bit unusual but also kind of sneaky tasty.
Shortcut: https://www.tastings.com/Calendar-Wine/Review-2024-06-06-New-York-Wine-Classic.aspx