Full Review

Fifty Star
Buy It Now

Fifty Star
American Single Malt Whiskey

Category: American Single Malt Whiskey

Date Tasted:
Country: USA
Alcohol: 45%
88 Points
Silver Medal
Highly Recommended
$39

Fifty Star
American Single Malt Whiskey

Category: American Single Malt Whiskey

Date Tasted:
Country: USA
Alcohol: 45%
Golden amber color. Grainy, piney, earthy aromas and flavors of caramel and vanilla, play doh, butter cream and ginger, and toasted orange zest with a velvety, vibrant, dry medium body and a tingling, interesting, medium-length finish revealing notes of malted grain husks, coconut butter and nougat, white button mushroom, and sesame oil and black tea. Youthful on the nose with a bit of heat but this also shows a lot of potential for the category and will please those that like the taste of barley.

Tasting Info

Spirits Glass Style: Rich & Full
Aroma Aroma: caramel and vanilla, play doh, butter cream and ginger, and toasted orange zest
Taste Flavor: Same as aromas with notes of malted grain husks, coconut butter and nougat, white button mushroom, and sesame oil and black tea
Smoothness Smoothness: Tingling
Enjoy Enjoy: in cocktails, on the rocks and with cigars
Cocktail Cocktails: Sazerac, Old Fashioned, Manhattan
Bottom Line Bottom Line: Youthful on the nose with a bit of heat but this also shows a lot of potential for the category and will please those that like the taste of barley.
Expand Collapse

The Producer

Fifty Star American Single Malt

The Producer
Expand Collapse

Their Portfolio

88 • Fifty Star American Single Malt Whiskey 45% (USA) $39.00.
Expand Collapse

American Single Malt Whiskey

Spirits Glass Glencairn Canadian Amber.jpg
Serve in a Glencairn Ganadian Whisky Glass
About
American Single Malt Whiskey
A newer and still-evolving category, American Single Malt Whiskey must meet the following requirements:

Must be composed of 100% malted barley.

Must be distilled entirely at one distillery.

Must be mashed, distilled, and matured in the United States of America.

Must be matured in oak casks with capacity no larger than 700 liters.

Must be distilled to no more than 160 proof and bottled at a minimum of 80 proof.

Top Rated for
American Single Malt Whiskey

Stranahan
96 POINTS
Stranahan's 10 Year Old Mountain Angel American Single Malt Whiskey Batch No. 4
45.1% $129.00.
USA
Stranahan
95 POINTS
Stranahan's Sherry Cask-Finished American Single Malt Whiskey
45% $69.00.
USA
Stranahan
94 POINTS
Stranahan's Sherry Cask American Single Malt Whiskey
45% $69.00.
USA
Virginia Distillery Co. Cabernet Cask Select American Single Malt Whiskey
94 POINTS
Virginia Distillery Co. Cabernet Cask Select American Single Malt Whiskey
46.5% $44.00.
USA
Cedar Ridge 2024 The QuintEssential Special Release Untitled Cigar Malt Project American Single Malt Whiskey
94 POINTS
Cedar Ridge 2024 The QuintEssential Special Release Untitled Cigar Malt Project American Single Malt Whiskey
57.4% $99.00.
USA
Virginia Distillery Co. Cider Cask Finish American Single Malt Whiskey
94 POINTS
Virginia Distillery Co. Cider Cask Finish American Single Malt Whiskey
46.5% $44.00.
USA
Courage & Conviction Double Cask Reserve American Single Malt Whiskey
93 POINTS
Courage & Conviction Double Cask Reserve American Single Malt Whiskey
48% $79.00.
USA
Courage & Conviction Sherry Cask American Single Malt Whiskey
93 POINTS
Courage & Conviction Sherry Cask American Single Malt Whiskey
46% $74.00.
USA
Stranahan
93 POINTS
Stranahan's Original American Single Malt Whiskey
47% $54.00.
USA
Shelter Distilling American Single Malt Whiskey
93 POINTS
Shelter Distilling American Single Malt Whiskey
45% $49.00.
USA
Bear Fight Cask Strength Small Batch American Single Malt Whiskey
93 POINTS
Bear Fight Cask Strength Small Batch American Single Malt Whiskey
60% $39.00.
USA
Courage & Conviction Sherry Cask-Aged American Single Malt Whiskey Batch By Brett Ferencz
93 POINTS
Courage & Conviction Sherry Cask-Aged American Single Malt Whiskey Batch By Brett Ferencz
46% $84.00.
USA
Oak & Grist Distilling Company 3 Year Old American Single Malt Whiskey Batch #04
93 POINTS
Oak & Grist Distilling Company 3 Year Old American Single Malt Whiskey Batch #04
46.25% $76.00.
USA
Stranahan
93 POINTS
Stranahan's Diamond Peak Extra Añejo Tequila Cask-Finished American Single Malt Whiskey Batch No. 002
45% $79.00.
USA

Best Buys for
North American Whiskies

Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
94 POINTS
Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
45% $21.00.
USA
Stillhouse Black Bourbon Whiskey
94 POINTS
Stillhouse Black Bourbon Whiskey
40% $24.00.
USA
Overbrook Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
93 POINTS
Overbrook Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
40% $16.00.
USA
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey
93 POINTS
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey
30% $25.00.
USA
Rebel Bourbon Kentucky Straight Wheated Bourbon Whiskey
93 POINTS
Rebel Bourbon Kentucky Straight Wheated Bourbon Whiskey
50% $19.99.
USA
Evan Williams Black Label Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
92 POINTS
Evan Williams Black Label Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
43% $14.00.
USA
Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
92 POINTS
Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
50% $19.00.
USA
Woody
92 POINTS
Woody's Fairly Reliable Am-Can Blended Rye Whiskey
40% $23.00.
USA
Watkins Apple Cinnamon Bourbon Whiskey with Natural Flavors
92 POINTS
Watkins Apple Cinnamon Bourbon Whiskey with Natural Flavors
35% $24.00.
USA
Bridge & Main American Wheated Bourbon Whiskey
91 POINTS
Bridge & Main American Wheated Bourbon Whiskey
45% $24.00.
USA
Deadwood Straight Bourbon Whiskey
91 POINTS
Deadwood Straight Bourbon Whiskey
40.5% $19.00.
USA
Kirkland Signature 6 Year Old Oak Cask Aged Blended Canadian Whisky
91 POINTS
Kirkland Signature 6 Year Old Oak Cask Aged Blended Canadian Whisky
40% $18.00.
Canada
Kirkland Signature Bottled In Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
91 POINTS
Kirkland Signature Bottled In Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
50% $24.00.
USA
Kirkland Signature Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
91 POINTS
Kirkland Signature Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
46% $19.00.
USA
TOP RATED FOR CATEGORY BEST BUYS FOR Similar CATEGORY

Fifty Star American Single Malt Whiskey rating was calculated by to be 88 points out of 100 on 9/22/2023. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review.