From The Archive

This review was done in 2022. We can no longer certify the quality level indicated below without reviewing a current market sample.

Submit Your Brand

If you are the brand owner or marketer for this product, please resubmit it for a current BevTest review by registering it at:

https://bevtest.com/get-reviewed/

If you have any additional questions regarding the submission process, please contact us at support@bevtest.com.
Expand Collapse

Their Portfolio

85 • Barbayanni Ouzo 43% (Greece) $19.00.
91 • Caruva Horchata Cream Liqueur 12.5% (USA) $13.00.
92 • Eis Minze Peppermint Schnapps 50% (USA) $12.00.
89 • Makaio Coffee Liqueur 21% (USA) $12.00.
88 • Risata NV Estate Grown, Prosecco DOC 11% (Italy) $15.00.
88 • Risata NV Moscato d’Asti DOCG 5.5% (Italy) $12.00.
91 • Sheelin White Chocolate Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $10.00.
89 • Sheelin Irish Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $10.00.
87 • Siempre Añejo Tequila 40% (Mexico) $59.00.
89 • Siempre Exclusivo Muerto Blanco Tequila 54.5% (Mexico) $119.00.
91 • Siempre Rebel Cask Maestro Blend Reposado Tequila 50% (Mexico) $84.00.

Archive Review

O’Reilly’s
Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur
Silver Medal
Highly Recommended
Category: Cream Liqueur
Tasted In: 2022
Country: Ireland
Alcohol: 13.9%

Top Rated for
Cream Liqueur

Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
95 POINTS
Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
17.5% $25.00.
USA
Asbach Coffee + Cream Liqueur
94 POINTS
Asbach Coffee + Cream Liqueur
15% $23.00.
Germany
Kilda Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Kilda Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
17% $18.00.
Spain
Forty Creek Butter Tart Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Forty Creek Butter Tart Cream Liqueur
15% $26.00.
Canada
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
15% $22.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Hard Chaw Strong Irish Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Hard Chaw Strong Irish Cream Liqueur
25% $28.00.
Ireland
Kilda Mango Tequila Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
Kilda Mango Tequila Cream Liqueur
17% $18.00.
Spain
Forty Creek Original Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
Forty Creek Original Cream Liqueur
17% $24.00.
Canada
Jackson Morgan JM deLight Lemon Icebox Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
Jackson Morgan JM deLight Lemon Icebox Cream Liqueur
15% $22.00.
USA
IRISH MANOR Irish Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
IRISH MANOR Irish Cream Liqueur
17% $16.00.
Ireland
Ole Smoky Mint Chocolate Chip Whiskey Cream Liqueur
87 POINTS
Ole Smoky Mint Chocolate Chip Whiskey Cream Liqueur
17.5% $25.00.
USA

Best Buys for
Cream Liqueur

Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
95 POINTS
Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
17.5% $25.00.
USA
Asbach Coffee + Cream Liqueur
94 POINTS
Asbach Coffee + Cream Liqueur
15% $23.00.
Germany
Kilda Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Kilda Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
17% $18.00.
Spain
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
15% $22.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Kilda Mango Tequila Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
Kilda Mango Tequila Cream Liqueur
17% $18.00.
Spain
IRISH MANOR Irish Cream Liqueur
88 POINTS
IRISH MANOR Irish Cream Liqueur
17% $16.00.
Ireland
TOP RATED FOR CATEGORY BEST BUYS FOR CATEGORY

O’Reilly’s Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur rating was calculated by to be 86 points out of 100 on 8/29/2022. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review.