About Irish Whiskey

The Scots most likely learned about distilling from the Irish (though they are loath to admit it). The Irish in turn learned about it, according to the Irish at least, from missionary monks who arrived in Ireland in the seventh century. The actual details are a bit sketchy for the next 700 years or so, but it does seem reasonable to believe that monks in the various monasteries were distilling aqua vitae ("water of life"), primarily for making medical compounds. These first distillates were probably grape or fruit brandy rather than grain spirit. Barley-based whiskey (the word derives from uisce beatha the Gaelic interpretation of aqua vitae) first appears in the historical record in the mid-1500s when the Tudor kings began to consolidate English control in Ireland. Queen Elizabeth I was said to be fond of it and had casks shipped to London on a regular basis.

The imposition of an excise tax in 1661 had the same effect as it did in Scotland, with the immediate commencement of the production of poteen (the Irish version of moonshine). This did not, however, slow down the growth of the distilling industry, and by the end of the 18th century there were over 2,000 stills in operation around the country.

Under British rule Ireland was export oriented and, along with grains and assorted foodstuffs, Irish distillers produced large quantities of pot-distilled whiskey for export into the expanding British Empire. Irish whiskey outsold Scotch whisky in most markets because it was lighter in body. It is said that in the late 19th century over 400 brands of Irish whiskey were being exported and sold in the United States.

This happy state of affairs for Irish distillers lasted into the early 20th century when the market began to change. The Irish distillers, pot still users to a man, were slow to respond to the rise of blended Scotch whisky with its column-distilled, smooth grain whisky component. When National Prohibition in the United States closed off Irish whisky's largest export market, many of the smaller distilleries closed. The remaining distilleries then failed to adequately anticipate the coming of Repeal (unlike the Scotch distillers) and were caught short without adequate stocks when it came. The Great Depression, trade embargoes between the newly independent Irish Republic and the United Kingdom, and World War II caused further havoc among the distillers.

In 1966 the three remaining distilling companies in the Republic of Ireland—Powers, Jameson, and Cork Distilleries—merged into a single company, Irish Distillers Company (IDC). In 1972, Bushmills, the last distillery in Northern Ireland, joined IDC. In 1975 IDC opened a new mammoth distillery at Midleton, near Cork, and all of the other distilleries in the Republic were closed down with the production of their brands being transferred to Midleton. For a 14-year period the Midleton plant and Bushmills in Northern Ireland were the only distilleries in the country.This sad state of affairs ended in 1989 when a potato-peel ethanol plant in Dundalk was converted into a whiskey distillery. The new Cooley Distillery began to produce malt and grain whiskeys, with the first three-year-old bottlings being released in 1992.Irish whiskeys, both blended and malt, are usually triple distilled through both column and pot stills, although there are a few exclusively pot-distilled brands.

Irish Pure Pot Still Whiskey is generally labeled as such. Otherwise, Irish whiskeys are a mix of pot and column-distilled whiskeys. Irish Malt Whiskey is likewise so designated. Standard Irish Whiskey is a blend of malt and grain whiskies.
Top Picks for Irish Whiskey
21 Year Old Single Malt Vintage Reserve Irish Whiskey
Brushed amber copper color with an olive cast. Layered aromas and flavors of dark raisin toast, honey butter, lightly smoked peat, dried peaches, and leather with a dry-yet-fruity medium-full body and a complex roasted whole nut, dried flower, honeycomb, and delicately smoky mineral accented finish with noticeable wood tannins. A very complex, long-aged Irish whisky for contemplative sipping and cigars.
98 points $199.99
Date Tasted: 5/29/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab
Rarest Vintage Reserve Irish Whiskey
Pale amber color. Complex aromas and flavors of caramelized roasted pecans, honey pastry, dried fruit, suede, brown spices with a supple, dry-yet-fruity and a very long and evolving, complex raisin chutney, passionfruit, creamy vanilla, and pepper accented finish. A superb marriage of grain and oak.
Date Tasted: 6/1/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab
12 Year Old Cask Strength Irish Whiskey
Golden amber color. Vibrant aromas of honeyed granola and orange gelato with a rich, fruity-yet-dry full body and a long, scintillating finish with a cascade of baking spices, toffee, and minerals. Rounds out beautifully with a little spring water. A superb Irish whisky of the highest order.
96 points $72.85
Date Tasted: 5/29/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab
Barry Crockett Legacy Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
Bright gold color. Lively, fruity, creamy aromas of peach pastry, creme brulee, and nut brittle with a satiny, crisp, fruity medium body and a warming, intriguing, medium-long pepper and baking spices, white chocolate, minerals, and flower patch earth finish. A superbly rich and complex Irish whisky for the connoisseur.
Date Tasted: 5/5/2015 in our Chicago tasting lab
21 Year Old Irish Whiskey
Golden amber color. Exotic aromas of passionfruit, guava, nettles, chocolate covered pineapple and honey buttered scones with a silky, fruity-yet-dry medium-to-full body and long, resonant ground grain, nougat, dried flower, and green tobacco leaf finish. A complex after dinner Irish whisky and a perfect foil for a milder cigar.
Date Tasted: 5/29/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab
12 Year Old John's Lane Release Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
Clear gold color. Bright, fruity, toasty aromas of frosted peach pastry, nougat, and white chocolate caramel bar with an oily, crisp, dry-yet-fruity medium-to-full body and a peppery, charming, medium-long baking spices, creme brulee, and dried fruits finish. A delicious and vibrant Irish whisky that demands attention.
Date Tasted: 5/5/2015 in our Chicago tasting lab
13 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey
Golden amber color. Delicate, creamy, fruity spicy aromas of cola, cherry chutney, and white toffee with a satiny, lively, fruity medium-to-full body and a warming, interesting, medium-length alpine honey lozenge, peppery spices, nuts, and minerals finish. A tasty and refreshing Irish whisky with a lots of appealing flavors.
94 points $99.99
Date Tasted: 5/19/2015 in our Chicago tasting lab
Dair Ghaelach Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
Bright golden amber color. Lively, attractive aromas of caramelized nuts, spicy fruitcake, creme brulee, and leather chair with a satiny, lively, dry-yet-fruity medium-full body and a peppery, medium-long polished wood, cornucopia of dried fruits, melange of spices, and clay finish. A fantastically rich and flavorful Irish whiskey with complex oak character.
Date Tasted: 5/12/2015 in our Chicago tasting lab
Knappogue Castle
14 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey
Old gold color. Rich aromas of honeyed raisins, blossoms, and buttery fruit custard pastry with a silky, fruity-yet-dry medium-to-full body and a long, grainy, nut, pepper and dried fruit driven finish. A lush, flavorful Irish whiskey that will shine with cigars.
Date Tasted: 6/1/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab
The Irishman
Single Malt Irish Whiskey
Rich amber color. Bold aromas of toasted fruitcake, praline, and creme brulee with a supple, fruity-yet-dry medium-full body and a lush, warming finish with notes of sweet baking spices, roasted chestnuts, pepper, grain husk, and mineral ore. A fantastic sipping whiskey.
Date Tasted: 5/21/2014 in our Chicago tasting lab