Best Buys

About Best Buys

Best Buys are spirits that deliver great taste at a great price. We use an algorithm that compares the ratio of a product's suggested retail price to our score in order to calculate our Best Buy list. If you are on a budget, these bottles can't be beat! 



For a more comprehensive list, or broader search options, please Visit Our Spirits Search Page.

Best Inexpensive Liqueurs

Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
95 points
$25
Best Buy
Ole Smoky
Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
An outrageously delicious multidimensional banana cream liqueur that is sure to satisfy those with a sweet tooth.
Awards: 2025 Best Cream Liqueur
95 points $25 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Asbach Coffee + Cream Liqueur
94 points
$23
Best Buy
Asbach
Coffee + Cream Liqueur
A very tasty coffee cream liqueur with natural flavor and instant appeal.
94 points $23 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
93 points
$16
Best Buy
Pennsylvania Dutch
Peaches & Cream Liqueur
Creamy goodness layered on to sweet fresh peaches; a deliciously guilty pleasure right here.
93 points $16 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
93 points
$16
Best Buy
Pennsylvania Dutch
American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
White chocolate and layers upon layers of delicious buttercream and caramel; will make a beautiful pairing with a mall cinnamon roll.
93 points $16 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
93 points
$16
Best Buy
Pennsylvania Dutch
Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
Like drinking a bowl of melted vanilla ice cream mixed with some fresh lemon curd and a shot of high quality vodka; don't act like you'd never.
93 points $16 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Merlet Crème De Melon Charentais Liqueur
93 points
$18
Best Buy
Merlet
Crème De Melon Charentais Liqueur
A flavorful fruit liqueur with melon and apricot notes — use to enhance sparkling cocktails and as an artisan alternative to Midori.
93 points $18 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Kilda Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
93 points
$18
Best Buy
Kilda
Strawberry Tequila Cream Liqueur
A clean, rich and well balanced strawberry cream liqueur for after dinner or dessert itself.
93 points $18 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Cherry River Coffee Liqueur
93 points
$19.90
Best Buy
Cherry River
Coffee Liqueur
A soft, delicious and artfully balanced coffee liqueur that drinks, and will mix, effortlessly.
Awards: 2025 Best Coffee Liqueur
93 points $19.90 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Bols Coconut Liqueur
93 points
$20
Best Buy
Bols
Coconut Liqueur
'Bottled Vacay', think the decadence of cracking a fresh coconut yet just by untwisting the cap — mix with fresh citrus and tropical fruits for a fun escape.
93 points $20 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted:
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
93 points
$22
Best Buy
Jackson Morgan
Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
For those that want to spice up Pumpkin Spice Latte Season, this is the only answer.
93 points $22 Best Buy
» Read Full Review
Date Tasted: